Clarification for Week 1 in Take Courage: A Study of Haggai

I’m grateful you’re doing the Take Courage Bible study; and, I want to give you heads up about a possible speed bump on Day 3 of Week 1 that could slow you down or trip you up.

Here’s the deal. On page 21, I ask you to read Ezra 4:24. And then my comments indicate that the people stopped working on the temple because they became discouraged. But, if you read all of Ezra 4—which you don’t need to and aren’t supposed to yet—you would read that the people were “compelled by force to stop” in response to an order by King Artaxerxes (Ezra 4:23).

So, what gives? Were the Jews forced to stop building, or did they get discouraged and stop building?

Although it logically looks like Ezra 4:24 is connected to Ezra 4:23 (which would suggest they stopped building because they had no choice), Ezra 4:24 is actually connected to Ezra 4:5.

Hang with me, I know it might look a little fuzzy.

Ezra 4:1-5 are talking about the opposition the Jews encountered when they returned and started rebuilding the temple. But Ezra 4:6-23 are actually talking about opposition that came several years later when the Jews were working on the walls, not the temple.

For example, look at Ezra 4:12:

“Let it be known to the king that the Jews who came from you have returned to us at Jerusalem. They are rebuilding that rebellious and evil city, finishing its walls, and repairing its foundations.”

Whereas Ezra 4:24 says:

“Now the construction of God’s house in Jerusalem had stopped and remained at a standstill …”

I know, it may be a little confusing! But, Ezra 4 is referring to two different construction projects separated by decades. Also, another evidence that the actions of verse 23 took place after verse 24 is that the reign of King Darius, mentioned in 4:24, took place before the reigns of Ahasuerus (4:6) and Artaxerses (vv. 7, 23).


You can check this out from Enduring Word Bible Commentary on Ezra 4:

“By the reign of Artaxerxes the new Temple had been standing for half a century.” (Kidner)

So, why did Ezra even stick this in there? The New American Commentary helps us understand this as it explains: “vv. 6–23 are a parenthesis to show the real attitude of those who offered help in v. 2 and to show the continuity of the opposition to the Jews even after the period of temple construction.”

Week 1 is meant to be a summary so I didn’t go into this amount of detail this early in the Take Courage study. But, I know some of my Bible study buddies will read all of Ezra 4 and may start scratching their cute heads in confusion!

So, there you go!

In the second printing of Take Courage, I’ll add a little note so future readers don’t get confused.

If you read this, it means you are digging deep and I’m super grateful you are! Way to go, you! May God’s Holy Spirit be your Teacher and Guide as you continue to study Haggai.

Bless you,

If you’re here from Can I Conquer Self-Doubt and Live With Confidence? With Alli Worthington [Episode 108] …

Go deeper into this week's question in my Bible Study Bistro Facebook group. There's a community of 4:13ers waiting for you!